Evaluation for Stage - 1

Stage 1 Assessment RubricTotal: 3.6 / 4.0

Each category is evaluated based on specific criteria and weighted accordingly.

S.No	Category	Weight(%)	Rating Factor	Score (Rating × Scaling Factor)
1	Problem Relevance, Impact & Target Audience / Beneficiaries Is the problem identified relevant and important to our society? Does it solve a social or community-related problem? Will the solution have a reasonably high impact on society? Can the impact be measured through concrete parameters? For example, how many people will benefit from the solution, will it enhance desirable statistics & reduce undesirable ones, etc. Is there a properly identified target population / beneficiaries for the solution?	25%	1.0	1.0
2	Idea Novelty Is the idea/solution novel and different / innovative? Is there local competition for the solution? Or international competition?	20%	0.8	0.8
3	Solution Practicability & Ease of Adoption Is the proposed solution practical and implementable? Does it have the potential to be easily accepted and adopted by the beneficiaries? (Technically simple solutions with a good user interface, and those that can be implemented without much user training and without cost input by beneficiaries are more easily adopted)	25%	1.0	1.0
4	Commercialization Potential / Potential for Mass deployment Is the solution commercializable? Does it need significant refinement to make it commercializable? (For ideas and products with a commercial or profit-making intention, judges to assess if the ideas can be easily commercialized given the facilities and expertise available in Pakistan. For not-for-profit ideas, judges have to assess if the solution has the potential to be mass deployed)	20%	0.8	0.8
Total Score (out of 4.0)				3.6

Criteria Details

1. Problem Relevance, Impact & Target Audience / Beneficiaries

Is the problem identified relevant and important to our society?
Does it solve a social or community-related problem?
Will the solution have a reasonably high impact on society?
Can the impact be measured through concrete parameters? For example, how many people will benefit from the solution, will it enhance desirable statistics & reduce undesirable ones, etc.
Is there a properly identified target population / beneficiaries for the solution?

Weight: 25%Rating: 1.0Score: 1.0

2. Idea Novelty

Is the idea/solution novel and different / innovative?
Is there local competition for the solution? Or international competition?

Weight: 20%Rating: 0.8Score: 0.8

3. Solution Practicability & Ease of Adoption

Is the proposed solution practical and implementable?
Does it have the potential to be easily accepted and adopted by the beneficiaries? (Technically simple solutions with a good user interface, and those that can be implemented without much user training and without cost input by beneficiaries are more easily adopted)

Weight: 25%Rating: 1.0Score: 1.0

4. Commercialization Potential / Potential for Mass deployment

Is the solution commercializable?
Does it need significant refinement to make it commercializable?
(For ideas and products with a commercial or profit-making intention, judges to assess if the ideas can be easily commercialized given the facilities and expertise available in Pakistan.
For not-for-profit ideas, judges have to assess if the solution has the potential to be mass deployed)

Weight: 20%Rating: 0.8Score: 0.8

Evaluation for Stage - 1

Stage 1 Assessment RubricTotal: 3.6 / 4.0

Each category is evaluated based on specific criteria and weighted accordingly.

S.No	Category	Weight(%)	Rating Factor	Score (Rating × Scaling Factor)
1	Problem Relevance, Impact & Target Audience / Beneficiaries Is the problem identified relevant and important to our society? Does it solve a social or community-related problem? Will the solution have a reasonably high impact on society? Can the impact be measured through concrete parameters? For example, how many people will benefit from the solution, will it enhance desirable statistics & reduce undesirable ones, etc. Is there a properly identified target population / beneficiaries for the solution?	25%	1.0	1.0
2	Idea Novelty Is the idea/solution novel and different / innovative? Is there local competition for the solution? Or international competition?	20%	0.8	0.8
3	Solution Practicability & Ease of Adoption Is the proposed solution practical and implementable? Does it have the potential to be easily accepted and adopted by the beneficiaries? (Technically simple solutions with a good user interface, and those that can be implemented without much user training and without cost input by beneficiaries are more easily adopted)	25%	1.0	1.0
4	Commercialization Potential / Potential for Mass deployment Is the solution commercializable? Does it need significant refinement to make it commercializable? (For ideas and products with a commercial or profit-making intention, judges to assess if the ideas can be easily commercialized given the facilities and expertise available in Pakistan. For not-for-profit ideas, judges have to assess if the solution has the potential to be mass deployed)	20%	0.8	0.8
Total Score (out of 4.0)				3.6

Criteria Details

1. Problem Relevance, Impact & Target Audience / Beneficiaries

Is the problem identified relevant and important to our society?
Does it solve a social or community-related problem?
Will the solution have a reasonably high impact on society?
Can the impact be measured through concrete parameters? For example, how many people will benefit from the solution, will it enhance desirable statistics & reduce undesirable ones, etc.
Is there a properly identified target population / beneficiaries for the solution?

Weight: 25%Rating: 1.0Score: 1.0

2. Idea Novelty

Is the idea/solution novel and different / innovative?
Is there local competition for the solution? Or international competition?

Weight: 20%Rating: 0.8Score: 0.8

3. Solution Practicability & Ease of Adoption

Is the proposed solution practical and implementable?
Does it have the potential to be easily accepted and adopted by the beneficiaries? (Technically simple solutions with a good user interface, and those that can be implemented without much user training and without cost input by beneficiaries are more easily adopted)

Weight: 25%Rating: 1.0Score: 1.0

4. Commercialization Potential / Potential for Mass deployment

Is the solution commercializable?
Does it need significant refinement to make it commercializable?
(For ideas and products with a commercial or profit-making intention, judges to assess if the ideas can be easily commercialized given the facilities and expertise available in Pakistan.
For not-for-profit ideas, judges have to assess if the solution has the potential to be mass deployed)

Weight: 20%Rating: 0.8Score: 0.8

Evaluation for Stage - 1

Criteria Details

Loading...

Evaluation for Stage - 1

Criteria Details